Posts

Richard III and the Princes in the Tower

Image
Richard III and the Princes in the Tower by A.J. Pollard My rating: 4 of 5 stars As a person that is fascinated with history, particularly English history and very particularly the Wars of the Roses, I find this book almost perfect. The conclusion it draws is natural, logical and based on fact. But if you are one of those people (that I am meeting more and more frequently in online forums) that believe that everything bad ever written about Richard is Tudor propaganda, you will not like this book. It is not anti-Richard, but it explores the facts, and the facts are that not everything that Richard did can be seen in a positive light and if you are not willing to accept that, you should not read this. I like it when a history book shows the good and the bad, I like the logical approach and I find it well-written and easy enough to be read, even if you are not an expert in history. If that is what matters to you, you will like this book. View all my reviews

The Princes in the Tower

Image
The Princes in the Tower by Alison Weir My rating: 3 of 5 stars The problem with Alison Weir is that she presents "the likeliest version of the truth" as fact, when what it is is "the likeliest version". As such, I don't think she spent sufficient time debating on the other options. Personally, based on my other readings, I agree that this is indeed the likeliest version of the truth, but my conclusion is not based on this book. In one of the chapters she mentions that the Duke of Buckingham's innocence would be debated in future chapters, but I don't feel it is debated at all. After Richard, Buckingham is the likeliest suspect, and I don't see anything in this book that convinces me, as Ms Weir says that there is no way that he could have been behind the Princes' disappearance and/or eventual murder (either on his own and for his own interest, or "guided" by others). Alison Weir transitions Buckingham from a man serving his own purp...

Categorizing people

It all starts with this link: 6 Outdated Myths Everyone Still Believes About Homosexuality Far be it from me to recommend a website like Cracked to influence your system of beliefs. But out of that entire article, I will quote one sentence that truly strikes a chord with me: It's situations like these that bring credibility to the concept of "pansexuality" -- being attracted to people, not genders. So why is it that we feel the need to categorize people based on who they prefer to be sleeping with? How would you like to be categorized for preferring blondes over brunettes (or the other way around)? How is that in any way relevant to the person you are, the way you are thinking, your brain? Is that what defines you as a person? Truly? Why is it that we make such a big fuss whenever an actor comes out as gay or bisexual? Why should that actor feel the need to do so at all? I could of course start a separate debate on why on Earth we would feel to know that about hi...

The Children of Henry VIII

Image
The Children of Henry VIII by Alison Weir My rating: 3 of 5 stars Alison Weir always tends to add her own input to her books but nowhere is this more obvious than in this one. In a non-fiction book she has added dialogue which to me is already steering it towards the land of fiction. Be very weary of that dialogue - there is no source to confirm it word for word, even if the sentiment behind it may have one. Other than that, while I can understand the focus on the reigns of Edward and Mary, I think I would have preferred more of an ensemble book, from birth till death kind of thing. Edward being a minor, his reign is more about his regents than about him so it's very hard to get a glimpse of who he was behind all that, which is what I would expect if I were to read a book with his picture on the cover. I have mixed feelings about this book. It's a good book to read, well written and such (I am referring to Alison Weir's writing style), but if you are interested in the ac...

Cleanskin

Image
Because someone pointed out to me that I haven't posted in a while and because almost every movie has a message beneath the surface - and this one is not even that deeply buried. Cleanskin is a movie about an agent sent to clean up on the hush hush, basically an assassination job meant to eliminate the people behind a bombing attack. And when I read it like that it was not something I felt too inclined to watch - but I did anyway because it was brought to my attention that there might be more to the movie than that synopsis. What this movie does, however, unlike most action movies in a similar situation, is present both sides. The suicide bomber's evolution from an agnostic studying law to, well, suicide bomber, is presented in more detail than you would expect. And the sad part is, it makes sense. I will not sit here and reveal to you the movie and how it manages to make sense of something most Western people do not understand. It's hard to understand - when all y...

Tudor Queens of England

Image
Tudor Queens of England by David Loades My rating: 1 of 5 stars From what I see, the book is targeted at people with a beginner-to-intermediate level of history. From time to time it skips over important events that didn't directly involve the book's characters (if I can call them such) but influenced their lives one way or the other by saying "it's well known how [a particular event] played out"... That's all good and well but then the author does some errors that jump out of the page in a book that should require at least minimal knowledge to read. Example number one appears in Elizabeth Woodville's chapter. The John Woodville that was executed by the Earl of Warwick was Elizabeth's brother, not her uncle (as the author calls him not once, but twice), the same brother that had married, in his 20s, a 65 year-old widow - fact that had actually been mentioned a few pages before that. It is relevant that it was that particular brother that was killed,...

Blood & Beauty: The Borgias

Image
Blood & Beauty: The Borgias by Sarah Dunant My rating: 4 of 5 stars Incredibly accurate for a historical fiction book. The historical notes at the beginning and end of the book will clear up any question you might have on what did or didn't happen. As with anything that happened 500 years ago, there are things we know, there are things we assume are most likely to have happened and there are theories that are meant to fill in the blanks but will probably never be proved 100%. The author successfully juggled through all of these, making up a version of events that matches all the facts we know about the Borgias and the, let's say, most agreed on theories on what happened. The only reproach I have is that she stops with Lucrezia's marriage to Alfonso d'Este. Yes, that was the pinnacle of success for the family and it is one way to end it, but I think many people, including myself, would be interested in a sequel that will cover their downfall - including Lucrezia...